How to see clearly through deceptive emotions | Kristen Lindquist

335,759
0
Published 2024-03-08
Neuroscientist Kristen Lindquist on how even on a biological level, emotions are entirely subjective.

Subscribe to Big Think on YouTube ►    / @bigthink  
Watch the full Perception Box series ►    • Perception Box™  

According to this neuroscientist, your emotions look different from those of someone who grew up on the other side of the world.

Kristen Lindquist, a professor of psychology and neuroscience at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, explores the concept of 'affective realism,' where our emotional experiences dictate our true reality. Emotions, Lindquist explains, are cultural artifacts, passed down like art or language, and are distinct reflections of both our biological makeup and our societal norms.

Individualistic societies like the United States and collectivist cultures like Japan interpret emotions like anger differently, leading to varied physiological responses. These findings suggest that there are no “universal emotional expressions,” that even facial muscle movements we associate with certain feelings are not globally recognized, but are instead interpreted through a cultural lens.

Lindquist's work invites us to consider our own emotional responses, encouraging a more open-minded approach to interpreting the feelings of others. Through this understanding, we can appreciate the unique perspectives each individual brings, to eventually unlock better solutions for understanding the world around us.

We created this video in partnership with Unlikely Collaborators.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Go Deeper with Big Think:

►Become a Big Think Member
Get exclusive access to full interviews, early access to new releases, Big Think merch and more. members.bigthink.com/?utm_source=youtube&utm_mediu…

►Get Big Think+ for Business
Guide, inspire and accelerate leaders at all levels of your company with the biggest minds in business. bigthink.com/plus/great-leaders-think-big/?utm_sou…

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

About Kristen Lindquist:

Kristen Lindquist, PhD. is a Professor of Psychology and Neuroscience at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill. Her research seeks to understand the psychological and neural basis of emotions, moods, and feelings. Her on-going work uses tools from social cognition, physiology, neuroscience, and big data methods to examine how emotions emerge from the confluence of the body, brain, and culture.

All Comments (21)
  • @_MrJA
    "Check yo' self before you wreck yo' self" is the best advice ever regarding emotions.
  • @emilyemr2591
    The space between what you feel and how you react is your destiny. Learn to control how you react to your feelings.
  • @hoykoya3382
    Statements "I am sad" and "Sadness is upon me" pertain to the same experience but have different effects on how we perceive it. The former statement tells that YOU ARE SAD and you cannot do anything about it. The latter suggests that you are just an observer of the experience of sadness. The latter is being aware and is very powerful.
  • @DmitriyOleynik
    I cannot recommend enough book "How Emotions are Made" by Lisa Feldman Barret for a deeper dive into that topic
  • @spirunk63
    Empathy, listening, hugs, smiles, support, respectful gestures, patience, forgiveness. The best gifts you can give to anyone belonging to any culture or ethnicity. We can do it🙂💙
  • @ingrid_K
    I hope it helps others too! Emotions come from thoughts. The first step is to think, and the second step is the emotions. Without thinking we can't have emotions!!!! Be wiser about what you think and how you think; you will be happy! 😊
  • @Hondeer
    My mom went to the ER with palpitations. They said the same thing, anxiety. Three weeks later, happened again. Emergency surgery for a stint. She's happy and healthy again.
  • @apextroll
    It is not facts over feelings, but feeling help to form facts.
  • Carl Rogers, Abraham Maslow, Marshall Rosenberg... Our emotions serve as finger posts to our needs/values being met, either in that context, or an historical one. Sometimes our environment can stimulate emotions that has no relevance to the situation in front or around us. This is the source of our vulnerability or irrationality. In this experience I find the best step forward is to merely acknowledge the emotions being experienced. It's been my greatest leap forward to simply pause for thought and say to myself, "I feel really angry right now".
  • @ahmetunaa
    I was listening this video with my head-phones and realized that at 1:58, her inhaling breath was clearly discrete :) and now I admired her x3 times more because I see how skillfully she is controlling her excitement and can be capable to stay relax and focusing the subject too 🙏🙏
  • @user-gq2sl5ry1w
    Thats why its important to have and be knowledgable about the situation at hand. Education over emotions. Choose Education
  • @user-pj6rs1gp2l
    The distinction between individualism and collectivism is really a interesting addition to this video. Both have their difficulties and strengths. It is a difficult transition but not impossible. I have to say, individualism is incredibly lonesome, seemingly unnecessarily so. I’m still trying to work that out. It doesn’t have to be cold prioritizing ourselves.
  • @dlsolof
    Love this! As someone who studied anthropology and socio-cultural linguistics, there really is a vastness to human experience, and how we perceive those experiences. We do the best we can with our limited understanding to try to make sense of what might be going on with other people.
  • @guru0503p
    One of the best BT talks I've ever listened to
  • @singhmaster4
    This is hands down the most intellectual channel on YouTube. Never disappoints. It is run by educated and intelligent people. I wish I can afford your paid subscription, but i cant at the moment. I know it will be a good choice.
  • @rookhoatzin
    Emotions work like the sensors on a car creating a "feedback loop" that not only informs us subjectively of how we are feeling but acts on an autonomic level influencing hormone production, heart rate, digestion, all sorts of other physiological functions. Emotions are a primary influence of body functions, not just attitude but many aspects of general health/wellbeing. Emotional control is perhaps the best tool we have to affect our health directly.
  • @sensukii6446
    What an amazing explanation of this reality, thank you for your knowledge
  • @ChrisoulaGirl
    This was awesome. Such a great presentation. Everyone should see this. 🎉
  • @FairyWasabi
    Ah, the intricate dance of emotions, as explained by neuroscientist Kristen Lindquist. According to her, emotions are not just a simple flick of a switch, but rather a complex interplay of biology, culture, and personal experience. Lindquist takes us on a journey into the world of 'affective realism,' where our emotions don't just reflect reality—they create it. It's like we're all walking around with our own little emotional filters, coloring the world around us in unique and sometimes deceptive ways. What's truly fascinating is how Lindquist unravels the cultural tapestry of emotions. From the fiery anger of individualistic societies to the subdued rage of collectivist cultures, it seems we all have our own special way of interpreting and expressing emotions. Who knew that a furrowed brow could mean something entirely different depending on whether you're in New York City or Tokyo? And let's not forget those so-called "universal emotional expressions" that turn out to be not so universal after all. Turns out, that smile might not mean happiness to everyone, and that frown might not spell sadness in every corner of the globe. It's like emotions are these sneaky chameleons, adapting and changing their hues depending on where you are and who you're with. Lindquist's work is a reminder to take a step back and really examine our own emotional responses. Are we truly feeling what we think we're feeling, or are we just caught up in the emotional whirlwind of our own making? By understanding the cultural and biological roots of emotions, we can start to peel back the layers of deception and maybe, just maybe, see a bit more clearly through the emotional fog. So, here's to Kristen Lindquist, the intrepid explorer of our emotional landscapes. May her research continue to shed light on the hidden depths of our feelings, helping us navigate the tricky waters of human emotion with a bit more clarity and understanding. Cheers to unlocking the secrets of our emotional tapestry, one furrowed brow at a time! 🥂
  • @kaylastewart2396
    I am so glad I stumbled upon this. Particularly the section on facial muscles movements. As an English speaker from the western world, whenever I first started watching K and C dramas, I observed that the way they would emote was a little off/differently than what I would expect from watching a western/English show. This all helps it make more sense.