Empire and Rebels vs. Republic and CIS: Who Would Win? | Star Wars Galactic Versus

Big shout out to Freighttrain for editing today's video. Please check out his channel (pls): www.youtube.com/channel/UC63cgt1JjPX5z9b6JqVVFZQ Also, I was away for four days testing out the final build of Battlefront II. I've recorded over 500GB of footage, and have lots planned for the channel :)

The prequel trilogy has mayor superweapons The high ground and sand...

The Republic would win cause they can watch out for those wrist rockets

Wasn't the droid navy crazy powerful because of sheer numbers and droid AI pilots?

This video makes it clear that the Rebel Alliance has the thickest plot armor in history of everything.

I like how this was basically the empire vs the cis and republic lmao

bruh imagine how awkward would a scene be with luke and darth vader teaming up against anakin and obi-wan

If the rebellion can take out the Death Star I think the republic and the cis could take them out

Personally, I think the prequels would win, but maybe that’s just because I’ve seen more of them through The Clone Wars.

Clones can aim Stormtroopers cannot. Self explanatory.

I think you kind of miss some aspects of the republic and CIS, the scale of engagement in the clone wars, as well as the doctrine and deployment of troops were much stronger than the empire. The republic and CIS could work in combined arms invasion of more planets than the empire could handle. Even if the ground forces of the empire were much better than the clone and droid forces, wave after wave after wave of infantry, highly mobile troops in drop ships, and much more mecanized troops would be overwhelming. That isnt even counting the CIS fighting in conjunction. The CIS could keep up an attack perpetually for weeks, never losing momentum, never sleeping, losses would mean nothing to a combination of clones and droids, and every casualty in the empire would be several times as bad as for the prequel factions. The empire is likely to suffer morale failure, each individual trooper would be out numbered severely, both clones and droids would never surrender, but troopers would rather surrender than try and hold on under overwhelming attack. In the end the empire's focus on large expensive assets could be their downfall, both the republic and CIS could attack these targets suicidally and unconventionally. The prequel forces would be able to keep up a war for longer than the empire, which would have to resort to mass conscription.

Every one talking about how big the empire ships were, and the capabilities but did everyone forget about BOARDING? Literally a team of ten Jedi, some arc troopers and tons of battle droids could board an isd and overtake it easily.

This video is a blasphemy...first it was CIS who planned death star plans and knew exacly all of its flaws

Clones are better then storm trooper. Unlimited supply of back up from the cis. The droids take the hits and the clones use their superior troops to fight. Easy win

Is "Navy Straganth" a joke I'm not a part of?

Who else zoned out and watched the things going on in the background lol

I Strongly Disagree. On the ground both the CIS and Empire Relay on Mass Assault Human Wave Tactics, both using low quality infantry. However the CIS has a significant advantage for 2 reasons they can produce trillions of droids and they have a focus on mixed unit military this is a contrast when compared to the Empire's nearly exclusive use of Stormtroopers. The Empire's army would go through complete hell trying to win any ground battles, let those be defensive, offensive, or re-conquest operations. Stormtroopers would get absolutely shredded by Clones under the command of Jedis and couldn't face the CIS pound for pound on Mass Assaults. In space combat our opinions differ massively on the Empire, if it were only capital ships the Empire could win. But the main issue is the Empire's sheer inability to fight strike craft. The Republic uses nearly exclusively carrier vessels in the form of the Venator, the Republic's whole space doctrine seems to be oriented around the strike craft winning the battle for them, yet again a direct counter to the Empire. Not to mention that the CIS is no slouch when considering strike craft droids, hell with such little point defense on the Empire side I can only imagine the damage sabotage droids similar to the Buzz Droids could do to the Empire's capital ships. I would actually argue the Death Star 2 is more of a crutch then a straight advantage, a crutch that is waiting to be knocked out from under them. With the Death Star 2 requiring massive resources to guard as well as the fact that it can only be at one system on a sprawling front. It would likely continue its waste of resource status, meanwhile under-guarded imperial systems are captured due to the Fleets Required to escort and reinforce the Death Star 2 in case of attack. This doesn't even account for something you even mentioned in your "5 Ways to Destroy the Death Star Without Its Plans" video, that Special Forces and Jedi would be the best to infiltrate and cripple the Death Star. That the facility's ungainly size makes it an easy target. Well it just so happens Jedi are in overabundance in the Republic supported by the best Special Forces in Legends and Canon. This doesn't even take into account that the Empire Politically is a horror show of over-extension, riddled with corruption in every aspect of government especially the military. I think the Empire would lose battle after battle. I give this handedly to the Prequels.

"The Empire was very good at finding things" Wut…..

Who wins? ME of course

I just imagine Imperial And Rebel fleets getting overwhelmed by hundreds of high quality Republic fighters and thousands of droid fighters.