Ranking Every Animated Superman Movie From Worst to Best

Superman vs the Elite has one of the most satisfying final battles I've ever seen in a film.

I'm so glad that "Death of Superman" (2018) won the # 1 spot in this list! When I finally did my DCAMU film marathon, Death of Superman stood out to me the most. No joke, it literally had me crying at the end! That alone had me loving this film! Thank you for putting my favorite Superman film at # 1!

Superman vs The Elite is like,my favourite Superman film ever. Aside from the writing being perfection. It has George Newbern as Supes. Which he just so happens to be my favourite Superman.

I really like All Stars. I think Clark feels more distant in that movie because of the knowledge that he is inevitably going to die, so he just focused on being the best version of him before the end. That said, I loved your video. Death of Superman truly is one of the gems of the DC Animated Movie Universe.

My dad had a lot of Animated superman DVDs, so this is gonna be cool

All-Star Superman is my personal favorite. It's amazing with great characterization.

One thing I'll give All Star Superman is of every single DC animated movie, the scene with Clark and his mom made me cry

Superman vs the elite is by far my favorite Superman film ever! live-action or animated

agree on superman vs the elite , surprisingly for me, it will be the one of the best superman stories , because they open up the morality of the killing and how superman believes that humans can be more humane, even when they dont believe that themselves, 10/10. And that moment where he's thought to be destroyed , only to appear a literal god with his powers at his peak and that godlike rumbling voice gave me chills!

The death of Superman movie actually made me a fan of the character after hating the character for so many years. The movie nailed the feeling that Clark was just a guy doing his best. He was perfectly humanized. Everything from his storyline with lois to the involvement of his parents, to his interactions with passersby and taking pictures with fans...Clark was a likeable guy, therefore it was easy to root for him and live vicariously through his power. This also makes the inevitable ending hit even harder.

All Star Superman was my favorite. It had my favorite characterizations

For the record, Superman didn't show any hatred towards Supergirl in the Superman Unbound. If anything, Superman showed plenty of love towards his cousin and even shows faith in her at the end. Superman was plenty likable in Superman Unbound, but clearly has control issues, which is a parallel to Brainiac. Superman is only controlling because of how he cares about people. Superman learns to be a little less controlling in the film. All Star Superman is a good film and it's comic book counterpart is worth the read. I honestly love all of the animated Superman films, with the exception of the Superman Brainiac attacks film, which wasn't all that good. I also don't like Superman red son, not because it's a bad adaptation, because it isn't, but it just uses the evil/dark Superman trope that is just overused at this point. Superman vs the elite is currently my favorite animated Superman movie. This is an okay critique for the animated Superman films, even if I don't agree with some points and even some rankings of the films.

All-Star Superman is amazing, but if we count Justice League: Apocalypse War then that appearance would be the best for me. Just the poisoned depowered Clark design was great and his transformation at the end.

Very impressive ranking and it's great to see Superman animated movies get some love as some of them are really love. You should do a ranking for the Justice League animated movies as some of them are very good. Excellent job and keep up the good work

all star superman came about as a story to portray him as a god, the way he was written in the 1930's. that superman could move planets and had not limits or weaknesses thats why he has an imunity to kryptonite.. so the movie / comic was meant to be a tribute the the original supes, and thats why its considered a good comic book. coz it not only has a good story but puts that version to rest peacefully

Great rankings man and honestly my favorite Superman animated movie is Superman vs elite because it’s really great story and a great Superman movie.

All Star Superman is a WAY better read than a movie. The book corrects all the problems you are referring to.

Superman VS The Elite is probably my favorite Superman movie ever even if some of the character designs are a bit odd but it’s exactly what I want in a modern Superman story, The Death of Superman probably comes right after, if we ever get a live action movie for that story (no, BVS doesn’t count) then I hope the team behind it makes it like that movie Edit:Ok, scratch that, I’ve rewatched The Death of Superman a bunch lately since I made this comment and now I’d say I prefer that movie

Thank you. I need to start watching these. I have been watching the Lego DC movies and they are amazing.

Ranking Death of Superman above Superman Vs The Elite is absolutely criminal