Undertale Yellow Flowey VS Omega Flowey

UTY Flowey benefits from the entire fight changing art styles with every phase, making the entire fight from start to finish feel uncanny and creepy, vanilla Undertale comes close at first but loses the immediate uncanniness pretty quickly

I like how both of the troll moments appeared at 7:33

one key thing that makes og flowey more dangerous is the capacity to still act against the determination soul even though it still has the real control over the timeline unlike clovers justice soul (ignoring genocide clover the goat)

As creepy as Yellow Flowey is, the face on the TV screen still takes the cake for me

I dunno why, but I find it themeatically fitting that, despite everything that Yellow's Flowey does, it never compares to Photoshop Flowey. He mimicks various artworks, but never matches Photoshop's look of... well, Photoshop. Realistic imagery compared to art.

This comparison contrasts how op the red soul is. While the red soul is fighting flowey with 6 souls absorbed, Frisk still manages to hold on for the rest of the fight until the other souls come to help you out, clover doesn't have that luxury and is at the mercy of flowey because he doesn't have enough determination to fight flowey on equal ground. Flowey only lets Clover attack because it's all just a game to him. When he got tired at the end, he effectivally killed Clover without any efforts. Moral of the story: Red soul too op plz fix :)

Wonder what Toby thinks of this? Does he ever think he was outdone by any fangame?

1 thing in favour of UTY Flowey(he can actually kill you in ,,soul" battle mode )while the original simply cannot

Imo the OG Flowey fight is better. Don't get me wrong, the UTY Flowey fight isn't bad. The artstyle change adds a lot to the fight, and the way he's presented is creepier. But what makes me prefer the OG fight is that the story context gives the fight more of a punch. Flowey has been hellbent on killing you and stole the only chance you have at leaving the underground by killing asgore and destroying his soul and taking the human souls to add insult to injury. With that, he overrides your save just so that he can kill you over and over again. However, throughout the fight the other human souls help you. And when they come together to take down flowey it feels so cathartic. The one who was trying to screw you over and override your save is going down. You're taking down a godlike entity whose whole purpose is to tormet you. To take him down feels outright cleansing. But hey that's my opinion.

I feel like the art styles, approach, and mechanics are fitting for each situation. Meta Flowey takes place in Flowey’s subconscious, where all the nasty intrusive thoughts go to die. It’s cruel and bleak and destroyed, more dreamlike than Omega because for Flowey to be active in this torment, he may be sleeping and dreaming of pain. Both sides have lost, so it’s time to start fresh. Omega Flowey is patchwork, something constructed of a destroyed reality. He’s so close to victory, so he attacks with reckless excitement. He plays with his new souls like toys, and for that they turn against him.

UT yellow Flowey: Inf Control over the timeline using every bit of determination they have to tear down the world into a Nightmare UT Flowey: his strongest Ability to shift the world was shifted by a Child of greater determination and His Second Source of power to overpower the determination by a bit being the souls are in constant denial of his control

Still prefer the original however that couldn’t really be helped as the original had much more emotional weight due to the circumstances and cost of losing

I friggin love the fight against inner flowey for going more insane At the same time, nothing quite makes me feel things like the soul sections and turnaround against vanilla flowey (not like yellow's story is trying to do that sort of vibes tbf) Both goats in the end

Watching Clover's gun attack in Photoshop Flowey's fight and Clove in the UTY fight rlly makes me think that the souls are trying to fight flowey from inside and are just reliving their memories- OMG I'VE NEVR HAD SO MANY LIKES

In terms of creepiness I feel like Yellow takes the win. Though in terms of difficulty I'd say its a tie.

To me UTY Flowey is a win through and through. No contest. Music is more to my liking, the visuals are more chaotic and creepy, all the switching artstyles... Hell, even the circumstances of the entire fight resonate with me. UT Flowey is about overcoming an impossible threat. It's hard, but doable and very cathartic. UTY Flowey? He literally plays with Clover. Like a creepy child that "plays" with ants with a magnifying glass. The feeling of hopelessness as he just gets bored and waves Clover a new chance to kill Asgore. Just... Chef's kiss The yellow striped petal stage really unnerves me to no end... This, plus "what would you like to do?" face with those creepy eyes... Flowey is a complete sicko, and UTY did much better job conveying that, IMO

So, can we call original Undertale "Undertale Red"? Since... you know, red soul and stuff

Undertale Yellow changes a lot, anytime I see the Yellow soul or a cowboy hat or a gun in Undertale related things, my brain rewires to “Clover reference?!”

UTY flowey is the clear win for me, as not only did you leave out the first phase which is absolutely insane in all the right ways and is great in its own right, but the fight is just about 10x more unhinged and out there it’s uncanny. The different art styles make it much more creative and unhinged, I would quite honestly be surprised if the developers weren’t high when they were creating this monstrosity. Plus the musics just better in both phases.

i feel like this can go as a meme of some kind like: Average Vanilla Undertale Fan: Average Undertale Yellow Fan: