The Super Mario Bros Movie (2023) VS Sonic the Hedgehog (2020)

Don't forget to give the video a thumbs up guys! It pleases the YouTube algorithm and will help spread the video! Thanks!

I like how they didn’t just make Peach a damsel in distress in the Mario movie. They actually made her a brave warrior who helps Mario instead of just waiting for him to save her.

It's a tie for me. Both are good. Including sonic 2. What i like most about these movies is theyre proof that video game based movies can be successful when done right

Sonic has a better story but Mario is a better adaptation of the games

I'm a really big Sonic Fan, so I thought I would share my top 5 favorite Sonic Games! 5. Sonic Frontiers 4. Sonic 3 & Knuckles 3. 🎂Sonic Generations🎂 2. ⚡Sonic Mania💙 & 1. 🔥Sonic Unleashed💜 #LetTheBattleCommance

I thinks its best you try sonic1 vs sonic 2

If Nintendo does make a multi-universe of it's brand of games to film, Sega should have it's own too. I'm looking at you Golden Axe.

I am looking forward to the next Sonic movie which has a great story and arcs to cover if its based on Sonic Adventure 2. I am excited and nervous to see what it will look like, but I just hope it surpasses the other two movies. On a side note, I know everyone is looking forward to seeing Nintendo adapt their other franchises, but I'm more curious about Sega adapting games like Streets of Rage, Jet Set Radio, NiGHTS, Yakuza, Skies of Arcadia, Super Monkey Ball, and others into films or shows

To me, both the Sonic and Mario movie should've been the archetype of good video game movies. I still love them, but they still could've been so much better. But I'm still surprised they turned up this good. I'll give credit to Illumination, they're greedy, but they're good at making something kids will love.

Toad told Mario that Luigi was in the dark world because Mario described the world that Luigi was being warped to when they separated. That's not rushing things.

Ever since this movie was a success in the box office it makes me excited for opportunities for other Nintendo games to get movies about them like Zelda, Kirby, Metroid, Splatoon and many more Maybe even spinoffs movies for Mario like Luigi mansion or donkey Kong country

The Super Mario Bros. Movie (2023) VS Sonic the Hedgehog (2020) 0:23 Story 4:32 Mario vs Sonic 7:23 Characters 10:07 Villains 11:44 Action

Man, Mario just gives you hope for the future, specifically how they do the other franchises. I loved all three films for completely different reasons. It cannot be understated how WELL they did our franchises justice. Sonic 2, however, is Mario's greatest equal in terms of execution.

As always, fantastic review!! Great point on the part of Luigi getting kidnapped and the rushed reaction after that. I hadn't picked up on that. On the Peach girl boss, even though she did the course in one shot, wasn't she trained to do it from a little girl? I agree, though, they should stay away from making anyone into Rey. Also, your somment about the Transformers is dead accurate. I'm so tired of the focus of humans. I want more of the Cybertron battle/story as I mentioned that in one of my videos. Thanks again for the review bud!

I’ve been waiting for this video for a while! Thank you for delivering such quality in your analysis videos! Do you think you could compare the Mario movie with the second sonic film sometime? It’s fine if you don’t.

This was a Versus video I was hoping you'd make! I love this! X3 I haven't seen the Mario movie yet, but I do love the Sonic movie, and its sequel even moreso. The Mario movie does look pretty awesome, though, so I'm definitely wanting to check it out. Especially considering that I was more of a Mario fan as a kid (when it comes to the games, anyways).

The Mario movie had an amazing animation team, but the acting and story were really undercooked. If they had gotten really skilled actors to play the characters, it would already be massively better. Keegan-Micheal Key had a phenomenal role as toad, Anya Taylor-Joy did a perfect peach, and Jack black’s voice matches Bowser quite well. However, Chris Pratt put no effort in selling the Brooklyn accent, Seth Rogan didn’t even try, and Luigi had almost no voice lines at all, though the ones he were given didn’t sound good or bad, very unmemorable. Meanwhile, the Sonic movie had Jim Carrey having a very colourful interpretation of Robotnik, James Marsden was quite entertaining, and of course, Ben Schwartz brought an entirely new version of Sonic to life, and did so masterfully. Where this movie has fault however, is in it’s faithfulness to the source material. I, for one, actually really like that they didn’t just go for the standard story we’re so used to. But, I can see how some would get upset that they don’t get to see Sonic and friends running around Green Hill. It seems so removed from the games, it’s hard to see it as a Sonic movie. Both series have potential, however. Sonic 2 and 3 seem to be bringing more iconic game characters and items (e.g the chaos emeralds, g.u.n, etc) to the big screen. And Mario has such a HUGE chance to be amazing. Hopefully, they will figure out how to get the story better next time, although unfortunately the bad actors are here to stay, most likely. I apologize for those who read all that brain dump.

The only characters from The Super Mario Bros Movie that I thought felt like and looked like Illumination characters were Francis the dog and the humans in Brooklyn

Imo 3: Sonic 1 7/10 2: Mario movie 8/10 1: Sonic 2 9/10

I honestly liked Sonic more because it felt like it put forth a bit more effort into its story (even though it's not that good). However, I respect Mario more for being animated.