John Vervaeke - Tradition as a Living Force

Published 2022-10-27
John and I also made a companion video which you can watch on his channel:    • Speculative fiction, post-tragic roma...  

John Vervaeke brings together cutting edge cognitive science with the ancient traditions of Neo-Platonism, Daoism, Zen, and others to illuminate the ways in which we can wake up to the wonder and beauty of existence, to avoid self-deception, to become wiser and live more meaningful lives in alignment with our callings in this time of existential crisis.

John's YouTube Channel:    / @johnvervaeke  

Support the Fantasy Creates Reality YouTube Channel:
www.patreon.com/benpatrickholden

Subscribe to Talismans Against Boring Culture, Ben's newsletter:
benpatrickholden.substack.com/

Ben's website: www.benpholden.com/

TIMESTAMPS
0:00 - Introduction
2:18 - John's influences and concerns for the meaning crisis
5:06 - The Mycelial College - what living traditions can we draw on?
7:04 - Cognitive science and the Neo-Platonic world
13:53 - Zen and Daoism - 'the philosophy of flow'
18:43 - Neo-Platonism - a profound living tradition
23:00 - The importance of practice
24:13 - Scientism Vs True Science
32:29 - Daimons, Calling, and Ecologies of Practice
40:44 - Why you need an ecology of practice (theory of opponent processing)
46:17 - Examples - meditative and contemplative, sitting and moving, best order of practice, solo and community
50:48 - Discipline and flow, or a collaboration between Chronos and Aphrodite
56:24 - Eros and catching fire
1:05:12 - Metacurriculum, wisdom commons, links to John's work and entry points for further learning
1:09:31 - Closing words
1:10:16 - Links to Ben's work and how to support the channel

BOOKS
If you want a quick but powerful introduction to the Neo-Platonic tradition as the spiritual grammar of the west, John recommends these books to be read in the following order:
1. Perennial Philosophy by Arthur Versluis
2. The Mystical State: Politics, Gnosis, and Emergent Cultures by Arthur Versluis
3. Platonic Mysticism by Arthur Versluis
4. Plotinus or the Simplicity of Vision by Pierre Hadot and Michael Chase
5. The Sovereignty of Good by Iris Murdoch

All Comments (21)
  • @andywilkinsuk
    What a fantastic conversation. John really caught fire in this conversation.... thank you Ben for providing the neoplatonic kindle and breathing your sensual wisdom into this dialogos that enabled the sparks to catch fire in the way it did..
  • @craperhoe
    I love the end, feeling the fire and eros of ideas flowing freely. Very enlivening!
  • @OfCourseICan
    If you get this: Happiness is NOT Conditional: Happiness is a Choice! Then you get Flow. And then can live in flow. I realised and learned this through John's work. John is a true gift. Read my short book : "Learned Unhappiness".
  • Boy this needs more views cause there’s a good chance you could actually see this comment… I’m glad someone’s bringing James Hillman and Robert Johnson into the dialogue! I just found their work within the past two years. Thanks for the great content with Vervaeke.
  • @BcClarity
    Living in the times. I was Here. Vervaeke reincarnation of Wisdom Vajrapani embodied. Namaste'
  • Well done, it's good that you are able to draw John out where he is discussing something anew, thank you both John and Ben. If I could be other series with John, The Elusive I, and Untangling the World Knot of Consciousness, and of course Voices with Vervaeke. Peace
  • @gettingtogive
    Brilliant conversation! John really clarified some key ideas better than I’ve heard before. Really appreciated this. Thank you both 🙏
  • @TheWizaard
    I think about that quote from that Stars song all the time! 56:40
  • The privileging of epistemology over ontology & vice versa is a pretty important issue & worth a deeper dive. Nice edification & opening of John’s thoughts & work, thanks.
  • Why math is crucial to science. It permits precise measurements and the means of affirming or disconfirming conjectures and hypotheses. It permits learning and growth, instead of mere guesswork.
  • @phlovejoy
    This conversation seems to take place in the same courtyard as Aldous Huxley's "The Perennial Philosophy". Edit: And now that I've reached the end, it would seem that instinct was right! I'd be interested in hearing a conversation between you and symbologist Jonathan Pageau. You both have instincts for patterns, narrative, and the intertwining of lived life and fiction.
  • serious play... aspirational imaginality ..... engaging the adjacent possible ... great set of cognitive tools crying out for a 'sandbox', a kind of ordinary person's ....... crucible.
  • @BcClarity
    Spiritual dilettante Chogyam Trungpa Cutting Through Spiritual Materialism. "The Metaphysical Mutt" syndrome 2022
  • @GogiRazmadze
    Thank you for this (and another - on John's channel) conversation. What I particularly loved was mention of polarity between spiritual bypassing and reductionist materialism mentioned in the first conversation. I strongly feel that there lies one of the main reason contemporary renditions of monotheistic religions feel so stale.You are basically left with two possibilities: conflate the two (bypassing and materialism) in the figure of Adversary or assigning materialism to Adversary which leaves god the role of ultimate escapist. Another topic I am deeply touched by is Tolkien's "On Fairy Stories" - probably one of the most profound e essays written on the subject of Restoration / Redemption of Man. BTW Given your interest in Inklings (Barfield in particular) and Neoplatonism - had you looked at Anthroposophy? It seems to be good starting point for many questions you mentioned. Best wishes!
  • @carbon1479
    52:22 - Oh, that sounds a bit reminiscent of Apollo vs. Dionysus in Nietzsche's 'Birth of Tragedy'.
  • @hanskung3278
    Wait whether it's Decartes or Plato or Hegel or who ever, we are always '"locked inside our minds".....how could it be otherwise?
  • @missh1774
    I once had a vivid dream about this very thing, I had first made mentioned of in the "remembrance" live chats https://youtu.be/lYuSNZHDlzE. In the bay, a surfer rode the rip out, instead the ocean drift took the surfer close toward the headland. There he peered down into clear water and saw fixed into the cliff side, a chester drawer. Further investigation of the item, revealed sheets of handwritten notes, gold bullions and a leather journal. Taking the items back to shore, an unfamiliar name was repeated untill the old man was found in his dingy dust filled room. At its centre was a large darkened oak desk and a black vintage type writer with the old man hunched over it. It seemed imperative to make him type the name. "Type C - S - L ." Frustratingly, the old man seemed reluctant to type the name. Still another attempt was made to type the name Ø - Æ - ∆ . Realizing the type writer needed updating, time seemed to drift out toward the dirty bay window and beyond the orchard fields. Checking again the mechanics of the key function, it became apparent it was easier to simply ask the old man, how his typewriter worked. If old man Tolkien had any last laughs, I spose it would be for his typewriter to refuse typing an old friends name hhh