Bloodborne Lore | The Choir and Eldritch Truth

Thanks to HelloFresh for sponsoring today's video. Go to strms.net/SmoughtownHelloFreshJuneYT and use code POGSMOUGHJUN16 to get 16 Free Meals plus Free Shipping!

This is a testament to the greatness of Bloodborne’s lore. Nine years in and I’m still learning.

WE ARE BORN OF THE BLOODCLOT, MADE ALBINAURICS BY THE BLOODCLOT

The Bloodborne lore teller we've all been waiting for

"We are born of the blood, made men by the blood, undone by the blood. Our eyes have yet to open... Fear the Old Blood." I absolutely adore Bloodborne great to see you diving into it the game it really is one of fromsolfs best

adore more bloodborne lore

God i am so stoked you are doing bloodborne. Other content creators dropped the ball hard on going as in depth into the source as you do. So pumped.

The phantasms in the brain makes a lot of sense. They filled the experiments' brains with water. A perfect home for a baby old one.

Faux-sefka was definitely giving birth to a great one instead of ascending to one herself. Her pose was a common birthing position and she’s talking about feeling nauseous and terrible. It’s also when the red moon is out, so her womb has also been ‘blessed by child’

Coming back from Elden Ring to Bloodborne is such a treat. And I though nobody makes Bloodborne lore anymore. Thanks Smough Town! 👍❤️

An agony of effort by Charred Thermos blow my mind with his insights on Bloodborne lore. Strongly recommend watching it all

Need more eldritch lore in our lives let’s be honest

Perhaps it is simpler than the explanation given, but I had always thought that Ebrietas was the Orphan of the Orphanage, an Orphan of the Cosmos, and that it acquired that name upon her arrival.

38:11 - 40:20 The stacked realities and cosmos explaination BLEW my mind. Never noticed you could see bits of the next nightmare/dream.

The collective hunger for more lore and more understanding is the best part of Bloodborne's metanarrative. It shows us how dangerous this hunger is, yet we cannot resist the urge to know more.

Also side comment to keep ideas from building up in a paragraph, the chimney smoke idea blew my mind, if you pay attention to the Cleric Beast bridge it appears to go nowhere but then you see it before at the Orphanage and I never knew why until now. As for the fall of the Choir I personally still think the Red Moon pushed them over the edge more so, I always felt as if there was some human element up there almost watching us to a degree that just disappears as the Red Moon appears, you can actually see the Orphanage in Central Yharnam (you really can see alot, Old Yharnam from the bridge, Byrgenwerth from the wind mill, The Mensis castle in the frontier, and from the Mensis castle you can see multiple Nightmare Frontiers below.) Regardless one thing I question is the Celestial children, its possible they were being birthed there but the note in the Lecture Hall says “When the red moon hangs low a womb will be blessed with a child.” This implies a celestial birth is a pretty significant detail, now we now for a fact the red moon is a condition that can only afflict certain areas, as Old Yharnam still exists in Nighttime during it with a normal moon, so maybe its possible that they have their own ways of conceiving children without the ritual, maybe “Making Contact,” but even still wouldn’t Rom hold them back? Or do they control Rom to a degree? Another thing I wished was covered is the statues, Bloodborne has alot, so many you kinda get numb to it, but some are messengers seemingly evolving into animals, other alien like creatures, and then the Amygdalas who turned out to be very real. And then in The Unseen village, you see unique statues of little alien dudes (on the side path of the gaol with a wandering madness) and then masses of human faces and arms that are covered in blankets, and when we get further into the village we see people having been sucked into walls and petrified. Definitely some of the kidnapped people probably consumed to form the One Reborn. But i now question every statue I see as either an artistic visualization of concepts, or foreshadowing of creatures we see, or literal corpses frozen in place. In the Choir there are several figured that have cloaks on, alien looking creatures clutching their stomachs, if there was a birthing farm I think these would be the mothers. And if so would Odeon be the father of each? Why would they be petrified after the Red Moon forms, as well as the Make Contact corpse? The Altar of Despair also has several organic like shapes in its architecture very interesting that things seem to petrify when “transported,” like Micolashes corpse. I suppose for a final thought is Ebritas a child if Odeon? Considering how the newborns look like her as well as seek her maternal affection (given the three before the Celestial Emissary boss room) is she the Holy Medium? Occam’s Razor suggests yes but at the same time its as clear as if Melina is the Gloam Eyed Queen, all signs would point to it being so but its not outright confirmed.

I'm so glad you're branching out to other soulsborne lore! Bloodborne has always been a favorite and I love to hear the deep dives from you! Keep going <3

I think they knew of moon presence, but made the fatal error of beliving the great ones where a unified force. Too late did they discover that Flora was hunting the children of other great ones, a predator hunting calves of gods.

This was such a great video! One additional subtlety I'd add to this discussion is the apparent difference between motivations of ascension for the School of Mensis and the Choir. The School of Mensis is noteworthy for their relatively populist approach to apotheosis compared to the Choir, the Choir's approach being elitist. Much like you outlined, the Choir was seeking their ascension as elites of the Healing Church and using the entire society below them as a resource to that end, while the School of Mensis attempted ascension throughout the entire Unseen village and as a massive group. While the Choir had no qualms about slowly working towards ascension while the city below them suffered and burned, the School of Mensis thought that the ascension of all humanity to godhood could not wait through the current catastrophe, and that is why they took such bold and reckless actions to beckon the Great Ones down to them rather than the slow process of the elites rising to the highest planes to meet the Great Ones on the highest planes.

That interpretation of the chalice dungeons as fixed pocket dimensions that preserve moments in time really makes sense when you consider the loran chalice dungeon