What Really Happened In The Lord of the Rings Books...

dwarven ring Narya? are you sure?

Thank you for this great video. I can tell you put a lot into it. I can't wait for more!

Great work!! Thank you for the video!❤😊👍🏽😁🔥

Sauron didn’t make the three Elven rings, they were forged in secret. The nine were a successful endeavor, but the seven arguably failed. The stubborn nature and hardiness of the Dwarves helped them resist the dominion of the One and in the end most were lost or claimed by dragon fire.

Cool to see another YouTuber doing such a deep analysis! 👏🏼 Don’t worry, everyone comments about my pronunciation too. 😂 My Ohio accent just can’t nail some of these elvish dialects. 🤷🏼‍♂️

My 9 year old nephew is just starting to take an interest in LotR. I need to brush up on the lore 😅 Gimme all the knowledge, so I can impress him!

It was an elven ring, given to him as one of the rings uncontrolled by the one rings. Narya. The ring of fire, inspiration, and the ring able to inspire courage in those lacking it. Thus starting the entire book of the hobit. Awesome story, but seriously check the back story. That’s why Gandalf was able to inspire the dwarves, bilbo, and the fellowship. Lore my man, it matters. 💛

I'm going to take a little bit of a middle road here on this. I love all the time and effort you put into creating this, and especially the fact you exhaustively cite and link all the artists/work you've used. Clearly a lot of time and effort went into putting this together. By that same token, I really wish (and perhaps maybe would be something you consider going forward) that you had taken the additional little extra time to look up the proper pronunciations for all various names and terms. I think it's quite unfortunate something that obviously had so much energy put into it gets tripped up by something so straightforward and simple to address. I got under 4 minutes in before deciding to write this once I finished the video. I still commend what you've put together here and hope you do more, just want the polish to be there too.

My favorite books and writer period unbelievable real life experiences helped forge these books he was a genuine genius and warrior.

Before the Silmarillion was published, 'Maiar' and 'Valar' were names in Appendix A and nothing more. Nobody knew why Gandalf was also named Olorin. When Sil was published, we looked up Olorin and knew for sure Gandalf was a Maia. So many blind references. We did not know the story of Luthien and Beren, nor how that paralleled the story of Aragon and Arwen. It was JRRT's personality he did the work to make the story internal consistent. One example is Frodo gets buzzed by Nazgul in the Dead Swamp. That woven in to make the story consistent with all the events in Rohan that evening.

Dear god, this must have been an undertaken

Your grandchildren are going to love the stories you tell them solely based off your voice.

Gandalf carried a dwarven ring?

Yes! This will be so good if its like ur other videos!!!

I really love vegging on your videos but daaaamn your pronunciation needs a few tweaks! Khazad-DUMB was a gooder haha. Keep the vids coming all the same 😀

Dwarven ring?

Your username does not lie

Narya was one of the Three secretly forged rings made by Celebrimbor for the Elves, NOT a “dwarven ring”!

Narya was NOT a Dwarven Ring. It was an Elven Ring. Please correct.

well, in the thumbnail i was thinking ET might of been in the books.