Most HEPA Air Purifiers Are A SCAM (There's A Better Option)

136,566
0
Published 2024-03-18
In this video, I present a staggering amount of evidence demonstrating that HEPA air purifiers are not as effective as Corsi-Rosenthal Boxes and other DIY air purifiers. I also talk to Wayne Westerman and Rob Wissmann, co-founders of the company Clean Air Kits that sells air purifiers that are quieter, more powerful, more energy efficient, and cheaper than commercial HEPA air purifiers. That's right: you DON'T have to build a DIY air purifier yourself!

This video is NOT sponsored.

This video is a journey. By the end of it, you'll learn exactly how to dramatically improve your indoor air quality by using air purifiers (AKA air cleaners). You'll also learn why you should. You'll learn about a better metric to evaluate air purifier performance so you can never be scammed into buying an ineffective unit again (Clean Air Delivery Rate, or CADR).

0:00 - Intro
1:35 - Research on the health impacts of particulate matter (PM)
3:43 - Why I started getting skeptical about HEPA Air Purifiers
6:12 - Clean Air Delivery Rate (CADR): a better way to measure air purifier performance
7:28 - How can HEPA air purifiers capture virtually all particles, but still leave the air dirty?
10:05 - What are the tradeoffs of the high efficiency of HEPA?
10:36 - Most HEPA brands don't even report CADR
11:05 - Some HEPA brand DO report CADR. Can we trust that number?
11:29 - RESEARCH STUDIES showing that DIY air purifiers (CR boxes) with MERV-13 HVAC filters are better than HEPA
15:31 - Can HVAC filters capture ultrafine particles?
18:08 - Why HEPA efficiency may not be as high as 99.97%
19:16 - Can CR boxes protect us from viral transmission?
20:03 - How CLEAN AIR KITS makes a quieter air purifier (PC fans)
22:18 - How do clean air kits compare to CR boxes and HEPAs?
24:00 - How can clean air kits be safer than HEPAs with comparable CADR?
25:44 - WHICH AIR PURIFIER SHOULD YOU BUY?
27:59 - BEFORE BUYING: how to size an air purifier to a room
29:42 - Wayne's air purifier layout strategy for viral transmission (THE EXHALARON)
31:42 - Are HEPA filters useful in other contexts?
32:09 - Are activated carbon filters and prefilters necessary?
33:29 - CALL TO ACTION

Clean Air Kits website:
www.cleanairkits.com/

Scientific research:
Ratliff et al: e9i3r2v2.stackpathcdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/…
Myers et al: www.tandfonline.com/doi/figure/10.1080/02786826.20…
Dal Porto et al: www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.01.09.2226897…
Srikrishna et al: www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9107182/
Holder et al: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36437679/
Review of numerous papers: ncceh.ca/resources/evidence-reviews/do-it-yourself…
Azimi et al: www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1352231…
Stephens et al: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23590456/
Chang et al: aaqr.org/articles/aaqr-16-10-tn-0437
Pawel Misztal's presentation (the figures about PM and mortality rate): tamest.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/Pawel-Miszta…

EPA article: research on DIY Air Cleaners to Reduce Wildfire Smoke Indoors: www.epa.gov/air-research/research-diy-air-cleaners…

Simple way to size an air cleaner (AHAM’s 2/3 rule): ahamverifide.org/ahams-air-filtration-standards/

Air cleaner selection tool: cleanairstars.com/filters/

Joey Fox’s amazing articles:
Is HEPA necessary for portable/in room air cleaners? itsairborne.com/hepa-filters-are-not-needed-67e952…
CADR is all that matters: itsairborne.com/clean-air-delivery-rate-is-all-tha…
Are extra features in air cleaners necessary? itsairborne.com/how-to-pick-an-air-cleaner-31c238b…

David Elfstrom’s article on how to do your own CADR test: itsairborne.com/how-to-measure-hepa-air-cleaner-fi…

DONATE TO MY CHANNEL: www.buymeacoffee.com/healthyhomeguide

All Comments (21)
  • @HealthyHomeGuide
    I wanted to address some of the comments and reiterate that this video is not sponsored by Clean Air Kits or any other company. I decided to feature their products based on my personal experience and belief in their effectiveness. I had no idea this video would be as big as it is! If any of my content is sponsored, I will always clearly disclose that to you. For those who are curious about why I didn’t name the brand that wasn’t effective for me: I don’t want to start a witch hunt of one brand when the real issue is the industry as a whole. I’ve seen too many internet witch hunts and I will not perpetuate that energy. It distracts from the real issue. Most importantly, not knowing the brand doesn’t matter because this video arms you with the information you need to make an informed decision for yourself. I also don’t want people walking away from this video thinking that HEPA filters in general are useless. I want to reiterate that there are numerous different contexts and settings in which filters are used. The type of filter required varies between them. MERV-13 is sufficient (or even optimal) in many of these. However, as I mentioned in this video, HEPA is necessary in some. For example, vacuums, cabin air filters for cars, powered air purifying respirators (PAPR), clean rooms, operating theaters, or nuclear laboratory exhaust. To add to what I said at 31:42: the Exhalaron by Clean Air Kits creates another context in which HEPA filters ARE useful. I’m referring to near-field source control, minimizing the spread of virus from a sick person to a healthy person. This scenario is different from reducing overall particulate counts within a medium/larger room.
  • @derpamine
    Homeboys air purifier so strong, his black shirt turned a lighter color mid way through the video.
  • @netsudro
    My wife wanted me to buy an air purifier. Me being a pc builder, I immediately thought: I can build this with some pc fans, a case and some filters for way cheaper. Turns out my idea was good al along. I was right! I'm going to send her this video. 😂 Wish me luck.
  • @4Deuroz
    Dude that's an INSANE video, the amount of research and effort is honeslty crazy. Customer all around the work should look at this video.
  • As a moderate allergy sufferer I've used HEPA air cleaners, always Honeywell brand which had/have cadrs of 300 or higher. The units have always sounded like small jet engines but I didn't care because being able to breath was more important to me and after years of using them it's a little harder to go to sleep without the noise. I got noticeable relief from them and never questioned their effectiveness until I watched your video. I have an email into clean air kits and intend to buy to compare one or more of their filter units. You should hit them up for a discount code for your viewers.
  • @user-fu8vn7xo6c
    Yes, the surface area of the filters matters. With Biological Safety Cabinets used in laboratories, or laminar flow hoods used in pharmaceutical work, the size of the HEPA filters are enormous in comparison to a household air cleaner. The larger the filter given the same fan & speed setting, the more clean air produced because of decreased resistance to flow. Most household HEPA air filters have minuscule filters. HEPA filters are superior IF the household cleaner is properly designed. Apparently they are not today. HEPA filters can last for many years especially with the usual setup of having a pre filter ahead of the HEPA filter. A pre filter is similar to your MERV rated filter. This is standard in a laminar flow hood, as described in USP797.
  • Very glad I found this video. Last week I purchased a Levoit Vital 200S-P as the home that I'm moving into has noticeably bad air quality and has shown worryingly high fungal presence in air quality tests. I decided to test it in my current home ahead of time, and after running it in a particularly dusty 168 sqft storage room on the highest setting for 8 hours I can't tell any difference. Not only that, but the machine had the audacity to say that the room had reached "excellent" air quality within 30 seconds of being on. I can't believe how many online reviews are praising this thing. As for a replacement, I'll need to find some more reviews first, but I'm pretty intrigued by the Luggable XXL. Thanks for gathering all this data.
  • @ShadowDaPk
    13:49 I'm not reading this the same way. The HEPA didn't generate as much cleaned air (lower CADR) but the air that came out was cleaned more thoroughly (higher efficiency). So the HEPA didn't move as much air, but the air that comes out at the filter has lower concentration of particulates in it, versus a lot more air coming out with higher concentration still "dirty". I feel like this is the part not being said directly here.
  • @DanielReskin
    Thanks so much for the information! I'm going to get one. Quick question - on average how often do you have to replace the filters?
  • @AlanW
    Is this sponsored content?
  • @dpanki
    I have two hepa filters in my home that has small rooms. I can't/don't want to have big footprint diy merv filter. Does it still make sense to stick with what I am doing when running those units on low 24/7.
  • @seethebutter
    Im a mechanical engineer. The vendors in HVAC have been trying to convince you of the “medical benefits” of HVAC widegets for at least the 45 years I’ve been in the field. Lmao
  • Use both. A merv13 will scrub large volumes to 25% purity and use hepa13 to clean it further. This way hepa is not going to be overwhelmed with particulate
  • Hi, love your info, trying hard to find a car air purifier that can stay in the car and get charged in the car, found a few but they had UVC, any recommendations for a car ?
  • @sandeeps_
    Is Levoit a good brand of air purifier? I have the core 200S.
  • @musicjunk8266
    what is the absolute best clean airs kits air purifier for a bedroom? The 6-fan Brisk Box?
  • @capcom4eva
    Do these kits work with 3M MERV 14 MPR 2500? Love your channel, just subscribed!
  • @kierand9410
    So…you bought the wrong sized HEPA purifier for your room. Common issue, with a common solution. Always buy a purifier designed for a room larger than your own
  • Hello Love this i am seeking a passive dust removal device / i am a thing collector, i have low thyroid and therefore dry skin and thus generate a lot of dust. i'm seeking a jetson's space age dust remover that does not require touching or handling the surfaces of the things or cabinets to clean. Any Ideas. thanks