The Most Forgettable Episodes From Each T&F Season

Gordon and the Gremlin spared the title of “Most Forgettable Season 5 Episode”? Didn’t see that coming

Alternate title : the most forgettable episode of every good Thomas season and season 12

Unscheduled Stops is most forgettable for S21? How come! Its the episode that brought back Bulgy.

I had no clue that “the grand opening” even existed

Percy and The Left Luggage is pretty forgettable.

I had a HIT DVD with The Fogman on it that I remember vividly. I also had a take n play of the fog machine, which might contribute to why I remember the episode so fondly.

I thought the Miller era was seasons 9-16? People usually call 13-16 the Nitrogen era.

For me, better late than never has to take the cake for most forgettable season 2 episode. I don't even remember what happens in it

What a fun ride! I loved seeing your thoughts! Here's my take: Season 1: I don't find any of the episodes in this season to be forgettable, but out of all of them, I'd go for Thomas's Train. It's just so menial and uninteresting. Season 2: I agree, Thomas and Trevor is the most forgettable one. That said, it's actually gone up a bit in my ranking, but it's still not that memorable. Season 3: There are so many forgettable picks this season, and No Joke For James would definitely be one of them, but I will also go for Thomas, Percy and the Post Train, because even after all these rewatches, I still can't remember it. This is coming from a guy who loves nighttime episodes but completely forgot the existence of this one. Season 4: All three Duncan episodes without question. I used to think they were all just one episode. Season 5: It's a tie between Sir Topham Hatt's Holiday and Thomas and the Rumours, for the same reasons: two loose plots that barely have anything to do with each other. I couldn't find any forgettable episodes from S6 and 7. All of their episodes all stand out and feel different from each other. Season 8: Chickens to School. I don't need to explain. I could say Thomas and the Circus, but that episode sticks out to me because seeing the human models move terrified me as a kid. Season 9: Thomas and the Birthday Picnic, which feels like a bad S5 episode. Season 10: I agree, Seeing the Sights is forgettable in the extreme. Season 11: Almost every episode in this season feels like the same boring crap, but Thomas in Trouble in particular. Literally nothing significant happens in it, and it took me several rewatches to remember who Thomas interacts with. Season 12: I'll go for Saved You. It's just so average. Season 17: I actually remember Gordon Runs Dry the least. It's just Gordon realising his boiler's leaking, that's it. Season 18: I was surprised to realise that Missing Gator exists, along with Long Lost Friend. They should've just been one episode. Season 19: If it weren't for its title, I would have completely forgotten what the plot of Lost Property was. Season 20: Bradford the Brakevan is a great character, but his debut is forgettable Season 21: The Big Freeze is the only episode of the season that I can't remember.

I never forget any of those ones from Seasons 1-10 listed here. All of them, I remember all the time. Especially "A Better View For Gordon" (though that one wasn't listed here). But the ones from "Seeing the Sights" to the rest I haven't really even watched.

Great video my friend, loved your justification as to why the Miller Era and BWBA aren't in the list 😂 The episodes themselves are justified to be on here as well. Well done my friend ☺️🚂🚃

I disagree with Season 5 being Oliver's Find, I feel like it's Gordon and the Gremlin

IMHO, here are the ones I'd call forgettable. • Season 1 - Thomas' Train • Season 2 - Woolly Bear • Season 3 - Percy, James and the Fruitful Day • Season 4 - Mind that Bike • Season 5 - Snow • Season 6 - Buffer Bother • Season 7 - What's the Matter with Henry? • Season 8 - Thomas and the Tuba • Season 9 - Thomas and the Golden Eagle • Season 10 - Seeing the Sights • Season 11 - Gordon and the Engineer • Season 12 - Percy and the Bandstand • Season 13 - The Lion of Sodor • Season 14 - Thomas and the Snowman Party • Season 15 - Fiery Flynn • Season 16 - Whiff's Wish • Season 17 - The Lost Puff • Season 18 - Samson at your Service • Season 19 - Henry Spots Trouble • Season 20 - Diesel and the Ducklings • Season 21 - A Shed For Edward • Season 22 - The Water Wheel • Season 23 - Diesel Glows Away • Season 24 - The Inventor's Spectacular Bridge

I genuinely love how you intentionally skipped the miller era and the bwba era. I honestly don’t blame you.

Honestly the most forgettable Thomas episode in season 2 for me was the runaway, like I don’t even know what happens in it, the only thing I knew from that episode was duck lol

A Bad Day for Sir Handel is one of my favorite S4 episodes, even in childhood cause as a kid, Sir Handel is one character I find memorable especially since it's weird how he didn't appear in between S5-9 until his return in S10 which even so is something we fans in that same category can all pick out on these strange things in the show one way or another.

I dissagree on Thomas in trouble. In it Toby comes to Sodor. I’d say it’s Thomas and the guard

I apperntly never saw a lot of season 10-11 episodes because when I was younger because i thought I had seen all the episodes by the time I was 8 and had internet access so I could see all the ones i didnt have on DVD, but there was some I didnt even know exsisted until a decade later, also i completely forgot the grand opening was a episode and not random clips used in music videos 😭

Great new video!!! 👍

For Me, I’d say Thomas and the Guard should’ve been the pick for season 1, But It’s Your List, Not Mine.