Netflix missed the point of Avatar

2,843,128
0
Published 2024-03-24
đŸ’» Thanks to Opera for sponsoring this video! Get a browser that’s literally better at everything, download Opera today: opr.as/03-Opera-Browser-DrewGooden

i'm gonna go rewatch the animated show now

00:00 - intro
01:49 - a terrible first impression
12:43 - opera
13:54 - what is the point of an adaptation?
14:29 - sokka/suki
18:14 - katara
21:05 - aang
26:45 - things I liked
29:30 - oh no i'm getting mad again
34:50 - outro

merch:
www.drewgoodenshop.com/

follow me:
twitter - www.twitter.com/drewisgooden
instagram - www.instagram.com/drewisgooden

All Comments (21)
  • @MrErik052005
    Katara being called a “Master” after obtaining 1 water bending scroll and having no training with an actual Master is as Disney/Marvel as you can get.
  • @nothankyou7979
    You didn‘t even get to the part where azula is now written as insecure and „lashing out“ instead of a calculated, cold-blooded and highly competent psychopath 

  • When Gran Gran said the name of the 4 elements I literally cringed so much my soul left my body and reached the avatar state.
  • @Gabby-dw5rt
    As someone who worked in TV development and left because it is run by soul sucking ghouls, I can almost assure you the reason the exposition is so repetitive and ineloquent and the characters are lacking flaws and are flat, is because some dumb executives didn’t understand what they were reading when they got the first draft scripts because they didn’t do their homework by watching the original series and won’t let the creatives cook. In notes sessions, they probably asked a bunch of questions (questions that get answered in time) and wanted to sound smart and like they had good notes so they told the writers to answer them sooner. I’d say you’d be shocked at the lack of media literacy in those rooms, but studios and networks keep churning out shows and movies that are like this, so you already know. The writers strike showed us the state of the industry and how little higher ups value the work of creatives.
  • @Spo8
    When execs hear “strong female character,” their only interpretation is “you mean strong like punching, right?”
  • Growing up as a woman, Katara was one of our ONLY positive representations of a strong girl who was also not only able to maintain empathy and emotion (something women and girls are belittled for) while being strong, but it often is what GAVE her strength. For them to completely strip her of that is just so telling of the story they were trying to tell and for who.
  • @lexis7003
    this was very effective. literally the moment your video ended i opened my laptop to start watching the animated series for the first time
  • @-_-0.0-_-
    weakening katara's character also weakens her connection to her culture. Water bending is about her connection to her people which is part of the reason she's so upset she can't do it right away
  • @Crysta11ize
    The fact that they felt the need to simplify the plot/exposition of a CHILDREN'S SHOW. Like they literally assume their audience has a shorter attention-span than a 7 year old
  • @nonameless2
    in the Netflix remake of "the emperor's new groove" kuzco is a philanthropic ruler who spends his days working with the peasants & is in the process of dismantling the monarchy when he's turned into a llama. He's the world's nicest guy and they ruined his life for no reason.
  • @IDK-xe6yg
    The visuals were exactly what I hoped they would be and the rest was exactly what I feared it would be, extremely disappointing
  • @aniekes3861
    Where is Katara's rage, her compassion, her nurturing, her emotions??? They stripped her of any depth and emotion.
  • A small thing, but the idea that Zuko could beat his father is more insane when you remember that he is a lack luster fire bender. Everyone in his family were better benders then him, his strength was sword fighting.
  • @novxmb.r9867
    ALSO the thing that pissed me the fuck off the most was the fact that they robbed Katara of her "motherly" role in the group. In live action Sokka was said to be the one that takes care of her and he is a "father figure" to her when in cartoon it was such an important part of Katara's and even Sokka's arc that Katara was the one to act like a mother to Sokka at times. I hate that they robbed Katara of one of her main personality traits which is her sense of responsibility and maturity. She was forced to grow up too soon they completely ignored that.
  • @_ikako_
    can't wait for Katara to discover blood bending by herself halfway through season 2 and use it to kill a bunch of fire nation troops and have 0 moral quandaries about using it.
  • We never wanted Sokka to be sexist. We wanted Suki to teach him to be better and we were robbed of that
  • @Ratciclefan
    It's seriously impressive that they got almost every character right visually but only barely got one character right in actual characterization
  • @palico004
    What really upsets me about this show, is that when I watched through all of the original animated series 2 summers ago my Dad used to walk in and take jabs at me for watching "a kids show" and I'd say its like the LOTR of kids shows but he wouldn't take interest. So I was encouraged and surprised last month to come home and see him watching the Netflix show, the bio and visuals piqued his interest. I didn't mention that it was an adaptation and just let him watch it. I came back later and he had turned it off, when I asked why he said the writing was cheap and it didn't seem worth watching. One of the best stories in TV and they couldn't even keep the audience they spent so much to attract. I hope he watches the original someday but its not likely.