Everything Wrong With The Martian - With Dr. Neil deGrasse Tyson
9,616,966
Published 2016-03-31
Next week: Dystopian sins and action sins.
Remember, no movie is without sin! Which movie's sins should we expose next?!
Tweet us: twitter.com/cinemasins
Tumble us: cinema-sins.tumblr.com/
Podcast: soundcloud.com/cinemasins
Call us: 405-459-7466
Reddit with us: reddit.com/r/cinemasins
Jeremy's book now available: theablesbook.com/ Merch: teespring.com/stores/cinemasins-store
All Comments (21)
-
He is actually a botanist and mechanical engineer, everyone on the team had multiple roles
-
It should also be noted that in both Interstellar and The Martian, Matt Damon's character is left by himself on a planet for a long time and is in an airlock that violently depressurizes. I guess airlocks hate Matt Damon.
-
"The only space blockbuster where no one dies." Wall-E would like to have a word with you.
-
See, I feel like for every sin, there's a perfectly legitimate counterpoint.
-
By the way: when you were saying that he is a botanist and shouldn't have so much technological knowledge, he also serves as the crew's mechanical engineer.
-
You can't kill this guy. He's fucking Jason Bourne.
-
I REFUSE TO ACCEPT THAT THIS MOVIE HAS ANY SINS ITS AMAZING
-
2:52 I love that scene. The "premature celebration" was very intentional and done better than in other movies. Give some credit dang it!
-
Not back wounds, thats rashes from malnutrition... that was one of the more accurate things in the movie I'm pretty sure. Super subtle.
-
Biggest problem with the movie: it was filmed on earth instead of being filmed on Mars, which would have made it much more realistic and authentic. A movie that takes place on Mars should also be made on Mars. Should have added 100 sins for that.
-
I love how Neil kept interrupting him pointing out how this movie/book was a masterpiece
-
Combined with just seeing a deleted scene from this movie in which he mentions the cost of his rescue, I think CinemaSins should do a special "What's The Damage" episode on the total amount of money spent rescuing Matt Damon across all the movies that involve him being rescued (basically every movie he's in).
-
CinemaSins: Tries to say anything Tyson: The Martian...
-
15:30 NASA actually DOES use universal power cords for that EXACT purpose.It also makes repairs easier.
-
Love that Dr. Tyson keeps stepping in to point out how great this movie is. And I will always have a soft spot in my heart for his movie after watching it with my father, and reading parts of the book to him.
-
Of course, in the book, Mark's also an engineer, which explains why he's so good with tech. And of course, the movie doesn't include that part.
-
"Matt Damon" -Matt Damon, Team America
-
The "rocket with a tent" would work on Mars because the Martian atmosphere is so thin, it basically doesn't exist. Atmospheric pressure at the Martian surface is 600 Pa, which is nearly nothing compared to 101300 Pa atmosphere on Earth. Thus the single most scientifically inaccurate part of the movie is what began the entire plot, as the sandstorm would only have felt like a light breeze due to the thinness of the atmosphere.
-
I think hearing Neil say "sciencing the shit out of everything" is the greatest thing ever
-
Usually your videos are good but with this one you're just trying to pull sins out of thin air, this is a pretty perfect movie.
