What Actually Happened to Dogday? - Poppy Playtime Chapter 3 Story Explained

I believe Dog Day said he was the last one & mentioned all the eyes on us to imply that he had to watch his words or the little ones would report his words to Catnap. It's quite possible that without Dogday to guide them, some of the Smiling Critters would have seperated or paired up. They were far too different personality wise to remain as a group without Dogday to harmonise them. - Some could have gotten lost in the factory - Some went insane - Some may have "checked out of existance" in despair - Some may have become trapped somewhere (think the Bunzo comic) & game over - Some may have turned to cannibalism if they were in a pair. I can't see Bobby Bearhug going anywhere alone. She'd DEFINATELY want a friend.

can i be honest about something does anybody believe poppy to be lying about a lot of stuff

That “hidden” room you found that’s a scrapped chase seen. Instead of DogDay chasing us through the play tunnels he was previously gonna chase us through that water ride thing.

Love this theory! Going along with your connection to the smiling critter episode because of the scream, could these voice lines from the cutouts just be vocalizing the individual “nightmares” each of the smiling critters would experience from the red smoke? I mean if I was picky piggy my worst nightmare would be being so hungry that I would even be okay with eating my best friends 🤷🏻‍♀️ and I feel like a lot of the other smiling critter’s voicelines would demonstrate a personal dream of theirs descending into a nightmare (although to be honest I don’t remember all of them)

I think a few are still alive. There were no screams at the end of Craftycorn's cutout and Hoppy's just ended in static which might not mean she's dead. Maybe one of them is using the name Ollie to help the protag and doesn't reveal his or her identity in case Catnap is listening in.

I know its very unlikely but i still have a little hope that Dogday can be saved.

I love the thought that some of them are still alive, but this is a cruel universe we’re dealing with and I think most likely they are all dead, perhaps we will see what is left of them in chapter 4

Crafty corn has a voice line after her scream, which applies that she’s still alive. I personally thought that the Bobby bearhug in the house was her actual self, but nobody is talking about it and there does appear to be a base so maybe it’s not her

If the pig is on the prototype’s side then catnap would have fed her friends to her, not necessarily her attacking and eating them. I thought dog day said cat nap uses the disobedient as food for the obedient.

My main issue with the theory is that the smiling critters only seemed relevant because of catnap. Now that he’s gone, I see no reason to bring back any of the others into the story

Think that the hour of joy was so crazy Bobby Bearhug is still a live some place. That’s wild to see a whole area cutout of the game. 🦖🎉🦖🎉Congratulations on 194k🎉🦖🎉🦖

Your voice sounds so calming when you speak softly

Rexter do you think it’s possible that? PICKY PIGGY it’s gonna be the next boss battle or bad guy. I should say bad girl maybe

I can say that Craftycorn may as well be alive cause there is another line that she says "There, thats better~" Many people miss out on this to show she could still be alive but gone insane

I think that the old theory makes a bit more sense, how Bobby bearhug and picky piggy is hiding but still alive but I think dogday knew that so that is why he paused and said he was the last one. So catnap doesn’t know about it. Also in the cartoon, at the end catnap is staring and the smiling critters are Lying on the ground meaning that they are “dead” and dogday is in that same cross position he was in at playhouse

what about hoppy hopscotch cuz picky piggy didn’t say anything about hoppy

You, fuzionzgamer, and dawko make a lethal company series

I kinda hope the bear and pig are at least still alive. With Picky being evil and Bobby still being good.

Nice video very interesting theory how all the smiling critters are still out there possible I do think your right about that. And interesting side note I noticed is picky piggy mentions eating roast beef which is made from cow could be just a random thing but everyone else is a smiling critter.

Honestly.. I'm having a hard time coming up with theories about Smillings Creatures. As far as I'm concerned, DogDay isn't dead, but I don't know what happened to him. CatNap is dead, though, I'm convinced. 🤭 I love Hoppy Hopscotch, so I admit I'd love to see them, but I don't know... I hear theories all over the place, and I admit to getting a bit lost in them. Yours is very interesting ! As are many others. But it's still a bit confusing. Maybe we got a little answer in the "Sleep Well" music video that's just come out? There's the Mob Games one, but the CG5 one at the very end looks like an episode of Smillings Creatures... It might reveal a few things. Music videos need to be analysed ! By you, but also by other people.