Why Did The Jedi Order HATE Revan after KOTOR...?

It's 2024 and Star Wars and Star Trek fans live in harmony... right? Please consider checking out today's video sponsor - Star Trek: Fleet Command! If you enjoy it, reaching Level 5 will greatly support the channel - strms.net/startrek_100starwars :_Lightside:

The Council wouldn't know the meaning of humble if it came out of hyperspace and ate their souls 💀

I love Jolee's quote about love, Revan proved the council was wrong about love by turning Bastilla back to the light. "Love doesn't lead to the dark side. Passion can lead to rage and fear, and can be controlled... but passion is not the same thing as love. Controlling your passions while being in love... that's what they should teach you to beware. But love, itself, will save you... not condemn you."

Of course the Jedi saw Revan as a heretic: He kept seeing through their dogmatism and proving their flawed beliefs wrong time and time again. Revan deserved a FAR better ending than the one he got.

They hated Revan (and Bastila to a lesser extent) for proving that love can actually save people from the dark side instead of pushing them towards it. Or at least that was part of it.

Kreia: "He has brought truth, and you condemn it? The arrogance!"

Jedi Council when Revan enters the council chambers "Is this room echo-ey or is it just me?"

Carth: What are you doing? Revan: Making chocolate pudding. Carth: Why are you making chocolate pudding? Revan: Because I've lost control of my life.

For me, it's simple: the Jedi Masters were terrified. The Order, down to barely a hundred Jedi, was weaker than it had ever been. The decision to laud Revan and fully bring him back into the Order was a desperate attempt to control him. The Council knew that if another crisis occurred, they would need Revan's power and genius to survive. At worst, it appeased Revan and Bastila so that they'd toe the party line and not rebel. Revan, of course, knew all this, but he had no interest in reforming the Order or getting involved in their politics. He knew that he was the wrong man for that. More, remember what happened after Revan was captured. The Council had the power to heal his mind. Instead, they violated his mind and imprinted him with a new identity, loyal to them. Revan was sureiy a bit peeved after that. All of that rambling is to say that Revan and Bastila likely knew that the Order was doomed. There was no fixing it. This is why Atris had no knowledge of Bastila's hiding place, or Jolee, Juhani and Yuthura. They all refused to return to the Order, especially after Katarr. Bastila only popped out of hiding to use her Battle Meditation when the Sith fleet attacked Telos. Even then, she avoided meeting the Exile.

Because they were jealous they didn't get a hot toy and Revan did

Monsters are humans created by humans and they used Revan like a monster to fight another one. The Order wiped his mind to keep him under control and likely keep their hands clean. In the end it didn't work, Revan was more than a traitor they believed him to be. Kriea herself later suggested that Revan choose to be a 'monster' to fight a greater threat that the Jedi failed to recognize/acknowledge. The Order got what it deserves in the end and deserves no sympathy. Hmm, future topics... Dart Bane?

And cue some 4000 years later and Revan looking at the Jedi of the old order who had passed on. Revan: "I believe this is the part where I say 'I told you so'".

9:14 "They would mock his marriage" is just kinda a funny thought. Revan walking down the aisles of the temple as Jedi laugh at him, "haha you love your wife, fuckin loser"

Because the Jedi council knew Revan was right in fighting the mandalorians. But they were still traumatized by the Great Sith Wars. Have no doubt that if it weren't for Revan, the Republic would have fallen.

because he was a hero, because he had friends, because he had love, but most importantly he wasn't their puppet, rather common issue with a jedi

As a Trekkie and a Star Wars fan, we more than get along. We have merged.

It always blew my mind just how dogmatic the Jedi Council has been at numerous points in Galactic history. And every time, without fail, it led to their undoing.

The council was jealous asf that they weren’t as cool as Revan

They hated him because they waited for the kotor remake and it never came out

8:02 Anakin would be jealous, what's next is Revan going to get the high-ground.